Comprehensive Moderation Guide

Guardian's Handbook

Everything you need to know about protecting the EveryTongue.Church community

Section 1

Role Overview

EveryTongue.Church relies on three tiers of guardians to keep the platform safe. Each role has distinct permissions, responsibilities, and training requirements.

Watchmen

Volunteer Monitors

Primary duty: Monitor live sessions via the threat dashboard.

Shift Types

MorningAfternoonEveningOvernightOn-call

Can:

  • Flag content
  • Escalate to moderators
  • Report threats

Cannot:

  • Ban users
  • Suspend churches
  • Modify word lists

Training required before first shift

Moderators

Trained Volunteers

Primary duty: Review flagged content, handle abuse reports, enforce standards.

Can:

  • Warn churches
  • Approve or reject community content
  • File formal reports

Cannot:

  • Permanently ban
  • Modify system settings
  • Trigger kill switch

Extended training with scenario walkthroughs

Administrators

Full Platform Control

Final escalation point with complete authority over the platform.

Can:

  • All moderator powers
  • Bans (IP, email, church, geographic)
  • Word list management
  • Kill switch activation
  • Archive scanning
  • Church suspension and termination

Responsibility: Final escalation point

Section 2

What to Look For

Content issues are classified into four severity levels. Each level determines the urgency of response and who needs to be involved.

CriticalImmediate response required
  • Hate speech or racial/ethnic slurs in translations
  • Threats of violence
  • Content promoting self-harm
  • Sexually explicit language
  • Non-Christian religious proselytizing
HighRespond within 15 minutes
  • Persistent profanity (not just one-time)
  • Political messaging masquerading as sermons
  • Financial solicitation targeting vulnerable people
  • Repeated keyword alert triggers from same church
  • Content contradicting the Statement of Faith
MediumRespond within 1 hour
  • Unusual session patterns (very long, very frequent, odd hours)
  • Single instances of mild profanity (could be accidental)
  • New registrations from geographic areas with high abuse history
  • Community posts with borderline content
LowDocument and monitor
  • Translation quality issues (not moderation, but worth noting)
  • Technical anomalies in session data
  • Minor community guideline friction
Section 3

How to Report

Reporting procedures differ based on your role. Follow the steps below for your specific position in the guardian hierarchy.

For Watchmen

1

Identify the issue during live monitoring

2

Note the session ID, church name, timestamp, and exact content

3

Classify the severity (Critical / High / Medium / Low)

4

File an escalation through the Watchmen dashboard

5

If Critical: immediately escalate to an administrator (do not wait)

6

Document everything - include direct quotes of problematic content

For Moderators

1

Review the flagged content or abuse report

2

Cross-reference with the keyword alert watchlist

3

Check the church's history (prior warnings, suspensions)

4

Make initial determination: dismiss, warn, or escalate

5

Document your decision with detailed notes

6

If escalating: tag the severity and route to admin

For Listeners (Public)

1

Use the in-session "Report" button

2

Select the category (cursing, hate speech, non-church content, inappropriate, other)

3

Optionally add details

4

Submit - the report goes directly to the moderation queue

Section 4

How to Escalate

Escalation follows a strict four-level pathway. Each level has defined response times and triggers.

L1
Level 1: Watchman Detection

Issue identified during live monitoring or via automated keyword alert.

L2
Level 2: Moderator Review

Within 15 minutes. Moderator reviews context, checks history, makes determination.

L3
Level 3: Administrator Action

Within 1 hour for High severity. Immediate for Critical. Full enforcement authority.

L4
Level 4: Emergency Response

Kill Switch activated. All sessions halted until threat is contained.

Escalation Criteria

FromToWhen
Level 1Level 2Any flagged content, keyword alert, listener report
Level 2Level 3Confirmed policy violation, repeat offender, high severity
Level 3Level 4Coordinated attack, platform-wide threat, active safety emergency
Section 5

Procedures by Scenario

Click each scenario to expand the step-by-step procedure. These cover the most common situations guardians will encounter.

  1. 1System auto-flags the content via keyword detection
  2. 2Watchman reviews context surrounding the flagged word
  3. 3If confirmed first offense: document and continue monitoring
  4. 4Second offense: escalate to moderator
  5. 5Moderator issues formal warning to the church
  6. 6If translation artifact: dismiss and add to exception list

Zero Tolerance Policy

  1. 1Immediate escalation to administrator
  2. 2Admin reviews transcript in full
  3. 3If confirmed: immediate church suspension (minimum 7 days)
  4. 4Force-stop active session
  5. 5Document fully with timestamps, quotes, and evidence
  6. 6Repeat offense: permanent ban
  1. 1Moderator reviews transcript or abuse report
  2. 2Verify genuinely non-church (business meetings, political rallies)
  3. 3Issue formal warning
  4. 4Repeat: 30-day suspension
  5. 5Third offense: permanent removal
  1. 1Multiple sessions showing coordinated harmful content
  2. 2Administrator activates Kill Switch
  3. 3Review all active sessions and recent registrations
  4. 4Block offending IPs, emails, geographic regions
  5. 5Lift Kill Switch only after threat is contained
  6. 6Post-incident report with full documentation
  1. 1Report enters moderation queue
  2. 2Moderator reviews within 15 minutes during active hours
  3. 3Cross-reference with transcript
  4. 4Determination: dismiss (false report), warning, or escalate
  5. 5Log everything for pattern analysis
  1. 1Review registration details
  2. 2Cross-reference against ban list
  3. 3If flagged: auto-reject and notify admin
  4. 4If borderline: place in pending review
  5. 5Admin verifies legitimacy before approval
  1. 1Auto-flagged terms in pending queue
  2. 2Moderator reviews full context
  3. 3Approve or reject
  4. 4If rejected: author notified with reason
  5. 5Repeat offenders: escalate for potential ban
Section 6

Tools Reference

Access levels for each platform tool, organized by role. Green indicates full access, amber indicates view-only, blue indicates limited access, and red indicates no access.

ToolWatchmenModeratorsAdmins
Live Stream MonitorViewFullFull
Threat DashboardViewFullFull
Word Block ListNoneViewFull
Ban ManagementNoneNoneFull
Keyword AlertsViewFullFull
Archive ScansNoneLimitedFull
Kill SwitchNoneNoneFull
Abuse ReportsLimitedFullFull
Church ManagementNoneViewFull
Community ModerationNoneFullFull
Full Access View Only Limited No Access
Section 7

Decision Trees

Use these visual guides when you need to quickly determine the right course of action.

Decision Tree 1: Content Flagged

Content Flagged

Is it profanity?

Translation artifact?

Yes: Dismiss, add to exception list

First offense?

Yes: Document and monitor

No: Escalate to moderator

Is it hate speech?

Immediate admin escalation

Zero tolerance - no exceptions

Is it off-topic?

Warn church

Formal notice issued

Repeat offense?

Yes: Suspend

Decision Tree 2: Abuse Report Received

Report Received

Is the reporter a listener?

Verify report source and context

Review transcript

Cross-reference reported content with session data

Confirmed? Determine severity:

Critical: Admin
High: Moderator
Med/Low: Monitor
Section 8

Best Practices

The ten golden rules every guardian should live by.

1

Document everything - timestamps, session IDs, exact quotes

2

Never act alone on Critical severity - always involve an administrator

3

Assume good faith on first offense (could be translation error, cultural difference)

4

Zero tolerance on hate speech - never excuse it, not even once

5

Check context before acting - a single word in isolation can be misleading

6

Protect yourself - some content may be disturbing, take breaks as needed

7

Communicate with your team - use the escalation channel, not personal messages

8

Review the Statement of Faith periodically - it defines what the platform stands for

9

Treat every church with dignity even when enforcing consequences

10

Pray for wisdom in grey areas

“Pay careful attention to yourselves and to all the flock, in which the Holy Spirit has made you overseers.”

Acts 20:28 (ESV)